Board Minutes: September 2011
350 West Georgia Street
Vancouver, BC
Canada V6B 2B1
Date: Wednesday, September 7, 2011
Present: Catherine Evans, Chair; Mary Lynn Baum; Carellin Brooks, Vice Chair; Angie Chan; David Chariandy; Kyla Epstein; Erfan Kazemi, Vice Chair; Debbie Millward; John Swift; Alan Twigg; Loretta Woodcock, Vancouver Park Board Representative
Absent: Mike Lombardi,Vancouver School Board Representative; Tim Stevenson, City Council Representative
Management Present: Sandra Singh, Chief Librarian; Diana Guinn, Director, Neighbourhood and Youth Services; Shelagh Flaherty, Director, Central Library; Ingrid VanKemenade, Director, Human Resources; Eric Smith, Director, Corporate Services; Daphne Wood,Director, Planning & Development
Staff: Jean Kavanagh, Manager, Marketing & Communications; Chris Middlemass, Manager, ILL/Sc&Bus/FA&His/SpCol; Daniela Esparo, Manager, North Area
Guests: Alex Youngberg, President, CUPE Local 391; Jane Curry, Member-at-Large, CUPE Local 391; Anne O’Shea, Project Manager, RFID; Stefania Alexandru, Friends of VPL
Recording Secretary: Chrysalyn Tolentino, Executive Assistant
PRESENTATION
1. Unit Introduction: RFID – Anne O’Shea
RFID Project Manager Anne O’Shea provided an overview of the RFID project, which is a two-year project with an estimated completion date in October 2012. Anne noted that VPL will install automated materials handling at Central Library and at the Terry Salman branch. She also enumerated the benefits of RFID including fewer repetitive strain injuries for staff, ability to check multiple items, increased self service options for the public, better inventory control and automated materials handling. The RFID Team will tag approximately three million collections and have reached the one million mark in tagging items a few weeks ago. The Board commended and thanked Anne and the RFID team for their work.
DELEGATION
2. CUPE Local 391 Collection Management
CUPE Local 391 President Alex Youngberg spoke to Trustees about the concerns of some staff about the rate of weeding materials at Central Branch.
ADMINISTRATION
3. Minutes
The draft minutes of Regular Meeting held June 1, 2011 were presented to the Chair for approval.
Moved by David Chariandy and seconded by Carellin Brooks
THAT the draft minutes of Regular Meeting held July 6, 2011 be approved as amended.
CARRIED
4. Election of Vice Chair
Board Chair Catherine Evans called for nominations for the vacant position of Vice-Chair.
THAT Carellin Brooks be appointed as Vice Chair effective until December 31, 2011.
CARRIED
REQUEST FOR INFORMATION
CUPE Local 391
CUPE Local 391 President Alex Youngberg reported that the union will participate during the September 23rd Word on the Street event and invited Trustees to visit their tent. CUPE BC National convention will be held in Vancouver at the end of October.
Friends
Stefania Alexandru, member-at-Large of the Friends of VPL, reported on the various activities such conducting a membership drive during the September 23rd Word on the Street, holding a volunteer appreciation event on October 1st, as well as book sale on October 27th. Stefania is writing an article in VPL’s Check-it-Out magazine and Friends has started a Twitter account. The Friends Board will propose that the organization lower their fee to boost membership.
VPL Foundation
The VPL Foundation is planning to organize a fundraising event on October 29th, the evening of the grand opening of the new Terry Salman Branch. Library staff will prepare an audio visual montage showcasing VPL & will feature two patrons who will deliver impact stories on how the library touched their lives.
British Columbia Library Trustees Association
Trustee Carellin Brooks reported that the BCLTA Trustee Orientation Program will be held at the Burnaby Public Library on November 26th. Carellin also reported that Board Chair Catherine Evans will present at the upcoming Union of BC Municipalities (UBCM) Convention on September 27th. The session is sponsored by BCLA, BCLTA and ABCPLD.
InterLINK
The next InterLINK meeting will be held on September 27th.
VPL Trustees
Trustees Kyla Epstein, Debbie Millward, Mary Lynn Baum and Catherine Evans handed out medals to participants of the Summer Reading Program in their respective liaison branches.
Trustee Kyla Epstein attended the BC Federation Labour Day event and the Friends of VPL book sale event. She noted that Seattle Public Library is also experiencing significant cuts to its operating budget.
Trustee Carellin Brooks gave the final speech at the recently concluded VPL Writing and Book Camp. Carellin congratulated the organizers for this inspiring and great program.
Trustee Mary Lynn Baum had an opportunity to visit Copenhagen’s Black Diamond Library that is noted for their fabulous structure but lacking the vibrancy as compared to VPL’s Central Library.
Trustee Alan Twigg informed the Board that the September issue of the BC Bookworld featured Chief Librarian Sandra Singh on the cover as well as an interview with Sandra, former City Librarian Paul Whitney, and Debbie Schachter, former Director of Technology & Collection Management.
ITEMS FOR CONSENT
Moved by Erfan Kazemi and seconded by Debbie Millward
THAT the June 2011 Financial Statements be approved on consent.
CARRIED
ITEMS FOR DISCUSSION & DECISION
5. Staffing and Activity Levels at the Mount Pleasant Branch
Moved by Erfan Kazemi and seconded by Debbie Millward
THAT the Library Board request capital and operating funding from the City to allow the Mount Pleasant Branch to maintain its current hours by installing sorting equipment to provide automated materials handling and increase information staff effective January 1, 2012.
CARRIED
6. Draft Board Evaluation
The Ad-Hoc Board Governance Committee has drafted its own questionnaire to assist Trustees to evaluate the Board’s performance in carrying out their roles and responsibilities in the context of the Library’s values.
Moved by Erfan Kazemi and seconded by Mary Lynn Baum.
That the Library Board Evaluation Questionnaire be approved in principle subject to further modification.
CARRIED
The assessment of the Chair will be shared to the Board Executive Committee and the evaluation will be carried out via Survey Monkey.
7. Youth Board Member
Trustees agreed to pursue the possibility of adding a youth representative to the Board and have asked that staff further investigate this issue.
STRATEGIC PLAN, DISCUSSIONS, AND ISSUES
8. Facilities RFP
The Library has received 11 bids for the Request for Proposals for the development of the Library’s Master Facilities Plan. Three candidates for the short list will be selected, notified and interviewed. The plan is estimated to be completed at the end of the year.
9. Capital Plan Update
The draft 2012 Capital Budget report will be finalized by September 20th, with a public referendum in November and the final approval by City Council in December. Library staff are in discussion with the City to adjust our funding for Levels 8 & 9.
City Archives is currently undertaking an accommodation study to see if co-location with the Library is viable and has engaged RPG Consulting to conduct the study. Through discussions with RPG, it became clear that the Library need to develop a master plan with a view to the future to fully understand the library service trends and needs before making a decision on the co-location of Archives at Central Library. The Library is now considering how to arrange for this work so it fits in with the Archives study work. Staff will provide an update at the October Board meeting.
COMMITTEE MINUTES
10. Draft Minutes – August CRPD Committee Regular Meeting
Trustees received the report for information.
11. Draft Minutes – August SFHR Committee Regular Meeting
Trustees received the report for information.
MANAGEMENT REPORTS
12. 2010 Annual Operating Report
Trustees received the report for information.
13. Terry Salman Branch Update
Trustees received the report for information.
14. DTES/Strathcona Update
Trustees received the report for information.
15. 2nd Quarter Board Summary Report
Trustees received the report for information.
16. 2012 Operating Budget Timelines
Staff have identified potential budget pressure priorities for submission to the City. These budget pressures include the Mt. Pleasant Branch, additional security for Central Library, and inflationary increases for non-salary accounts.
17. Activity Reports: Central and Branches
Trustees received the report for information. Trustee Erfan Kazemi extended his kudos to the children’s librarians at the Firehall Branch for their excellent work.
18. CULC/CBUC White Paper on eBooks in Canadian Public Libraries
Trustees received the report for information. Chief Librarian Sandra Singh will forward Trustee feedback to the Online Information & News Manager regarding the proposal to support diversity of vendors especially for academic journals.
19. Correspondence
The Board received the following from:
- June 10/11, Letter from Brett Waytuck, Saskatchewan Ministry of Education Provincial Director & Executive Director to Chief Librarian Sandra Singh re: VPL’s support for Philip Hall’s presentation to Saskatchewan public library directors and board chairs.
- July 15/11, Letter from Chief Librarian Sandra Singh to Byan Pike, Word on the Street Executive Director re: VPL’s support to WOTS.
- July 21/11, Letter from PLSB Director Jacqueline van Dyk re: Nomination of the VPL Early Years Program Team for the 2011 Council of the Federation Literacy Award.
- July 21/11, Letter from Sharon Freeman, InterLINK Board Chair to VPL Board Chair Catherine Evans re: compensation to VPL as the regional resource provider to members of other InterLINK libraries in 2010.
- July 29/11, Letter from VPL Board Chair Catherine Evans to Friends of VPL President Corinne Durston re: Friends of VPL donation to the Library.
- August 2/11, Letter from Chief Librarian Sandra Singh to Citizenship & immigration Canada Minister Jason Kenney re: Vancouver Board of Trade Luncheon
- August 2/11, Letter from Chief Librarian Sandra Singh to James Moore, Minister of Canadian Heritage and Official Languages re: Vancouver Board of Trade Luncheon.
- August 16/11, Letter from VPL Board Chair Catherine Evans to Eman Ahmed, Chair, Toronto Public Library re: Toronto budget situation in the news.
- August 16/11, Email from VPL Board Chair Catherine Evans to Timothy Renshaw, Editor, Business in Vancouver in response to the column written by Peter Ladner in BIV’s August 9-15 edition.
ADJOURN
There being no further business, the Chair declared the meeting adjourned at 7:48 p.m. and moved to in-camera.
Signed by: Catherine Evans, Chair and Sandra Singh, Secretary